JUST BECAUSE THEY CALL YOU AN INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR DOESN’T MEAN YOU ARE.
You bring the skill. You teach the class. And if they call you a contractor, you may be paying their share of payroll taxes too. Five questions tell you.
CLASSIFICATIONPAY & POWERTHE COST OF PASSIONAND THAT’S BAD FORM.
THE QUESTIONS WE’RE ASKING
LET’S TALK ABOUT THE BAD FORM.
A critical look at the business practices behind the feel-good promises.
01 / CULTURE & ACCOUNTABILITY
“WE’RE FAMILY.” UNTIL YOU ASK ABOUT THE PAY.
They don’t get to call you family and treat questions about your livelihood as disloyalty.
Follow the question ↗
Belonging matters. So do clear pay terms, reasonable expectations, and room to ask difficult questions. When “family” becomes a reason to accept less or stay silent, it deserves scrutiny.
02 / THE COST OF PASSION
EXPLOITATION DOESN’T ALWAYS LOOK LIKE IT.
Sometimes it comes with a great playlist, a packed class, and the expectation that loving your job should be enough.
Look past the perks ↗
Enjoying the work doesn’t make its terms fair. Look at what you’re expected to do, what you’re paid for, and what risks you carry. The question is what the relationship asks of you, not how much you love teaching.
03 / CLASSIFICATION
WHO’S REALLY IN CONTROL?
The schedule. The method. The money. Start asking who makes the decisions.
Start with five questions ↗
The guide helps you examine your working relationship. Its questions are clues, not a scorecard or an individual determination.
THE STANDARD SHOULD BE HIGHER.
FOR INSTRUCTORS. FOR OWNERS. FOR THE INDUSTRY.
AN INDUSTRY THAT SELLS WELLNESS SHOULD ANSWER FOR HOW IT TREATS ITS WORKERS.
Passion is not a substitute for fair treatment. A beautiful studio is not a reason to stop asking questions.
7.65%. That’s the employer’s share of Social Security and Medicare. Classify an instructor as a contractor and that bill moves from the studio’s ledger to yours. On $55,000 of classes, more than $4,200 a year. Out of your pocket. Into the studio’s margin.
It only takes one. One instructor asks whether they were really a contractor, and suddenly the question isn’t about them. It’s about every instructor on the roster, and every year that came before.
Get hurt teaching, and there is no workers’ comp waiting for you. Contractors absorb their own injuries too.
AN OWNER ASKING HARDER QUESTIONS
I WORK IN THIS INDUSTRY. THAT’S WHY I’M ASKING.
I’m Jess Schindler, founder and CEO of Citizen Pilates and creator of The Bad Form Report. This publication is a separate space to examine how boutique fitness instructors are classified, paid, and treated.
I believe owners should be willing to explain the practices their businesses depend on. And instructors should be able to understand the terms of the careers they’re building.
My instructors are employees, and I pay the employer share of their payroll taxes, which costs more than handing them a 1099 and letting them absorb the bill themselves. That is not generosity; it is the job, the same job I have done myself in more than 5,000 classes. Since 2017, doing it that way has meant paying more than $300,000 in employer payroll taxes that a contractor model would have pushed onto the people teaching in my studios.
We start with the questions that are too easy to avoid. If you own a studio and you’re reading this with an email you don’t use: your instructors are reading it with theirs.